Set in a rural French village in the late 19th century, La main de Sainte Modestine follows Clémence, a thoughtful and observant young woman. Her life, and the life of her village, is turned upside down when she discovers what appears to be the ancient, preserved hand of their beloved Saint Modestine. The local priest and townsfolk hail it as a miraculous sign, a boost for their struggling community. Pilgrims arrive, hope is renewed, and the village finds a new purpose.

The Story

But Clémence isn't convinced. Little details bother her—the too-perfect condition of the relic, vague stories about its origin, and the sudden, intense fervor of those in charge. As she quietly asks questions, she meets resistance. The priest urges faith over doubt. Her family worries about causing trouble. Yet, Clémence persists, following a trail of half-truths and evasions. Her personal investigation becomes a quiet rebellion, pitting her inner certainty against the comfortable beliefs of everyone around her. The central mystery isn't a bloody crime, but a spiritual one: is this sacred object real, or a well-meaning (or perhaps not so well-meaning) deception?

Why You Should Read It

What grabbed me was how modern Clémence feels. Her struggle isn't with grand villains, but with the pressure to conform, to accept the story everyone else loves. Schultz writes her with such quiet intensity. You feel her isolation and her courage. The book is also a fascinating snapshot of its time, exploring how communities build identity around shared stories. It doesn't mock faith; instead, it respectfully questions what happens when faith is manipulated, and honors the courage it takes to seek an honest answer, even if it's painful.

Final Verdict

This book is perfect for readers who love historical fiction that focuses on internal conflict and social dynamics over sweeping battles. If you enjoyed the muted tension of novels like Ethan Frome or the moral complexities in some of George Eliot's work, you'll find a kindred spirit here. It’s a slower, character-rich story that rewards patience with genuine psychological depth. A truly hidden treasure from the past that speaks clearly to the present.